One type of legal liability is criminal. It has clearly defined characteristics, varieties and characteristics. Involves the incurrence of various punishments for a particular offense by the guilty person. It is important to understand the nuance of criminal liability.
What is criminal liability?
In the modern world, there are several classifications of offenses according to the severity and penalties applied. All types of legal liability are usually divided into:
- criminal;
- administrative;
- civil law;
- disciplinary.
The most severe of them can be called criminal liability. It is researched and analyzed by various legal figures, but the legislation itself does not provide a clear definition of the term. In the broadest sense of the word, the concept of criminal liability is considered as a system of measures that state bodies apply to a specific person or persons who have committed unlawful acts.
Signs of criminal liability
This type of legal liability has very specific characteristics:
- Its grounds and limits are strictly enshrined in the country’s Criminal Code, which is the main legal regulatory document.
- This type of punishment is applied by the state (specially created bodies) forcibly.
- There is a special procedure for imposing criminal liability on a criminal only by court decision.
- It is of a purely personal and individual nature, that is, it applies only to the person who committed the crime.
Types of criminal liability
Many lawyers support the theory that this form of legal liability can be considered in two aspects:
- Positive
criminal liability. That is, this is the absence of offenses on the part of a person who complies with all the requirements of the current legislation. It can be considered as a positive assessment of an individual’s behavior by the state, excluding the use of punishment and encouraging such actions and lifestyles. - Negative
, also called retrospective. This includes repressive measures of punishment by the state for committing illegal actions specified by law.
Procedural acts
Depending on the stage at which the criminal case is being considered, documents of procedural significance differ.
In this case, we are talking about the fact that when investigating a case, the investigative authorities produce one type of documentation, but when the case is transferred to court, another one.
What documents document the fact of committing a crime?
Depending on which category the criminal act belongs to: private prosecution or public, the document that will be the basis for initiating a criminal case differs.
If we are talking about a private category or a private-public category, then the reason for issuing a decision to initiate a criminal case is a statement drawn up by the victim.
If it is of a public nature, then initiation is carried out on the basis of a report of a crime.
Further, as the criminal case is investigated, the following acts are issued:
- search protocol;
- carrying out excavation;
- resolution on bringing in as a suspect and others.
What documents can the culprit draw up?
The acts that can be executed by the perpetrator depend on the status of the person and what rights he is entitled to.
If we are talking about a suspect, then he can file petitions and challenges. It is also vested with the right to write a complaint against actions or inactions or decisions made by a court, prosecutor, or investigator. In addition to the listed documents, the accused is given the right to write objections to the termination of the criminal case. It is also possible to submit comments regarding the minutes of the court hearing.
Download for viewing and printing:
Chapter 16 of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation “Appealing against actions and decisions of the court and officials carrying out criminal proceedings”
Review of documents
Petitions filed during a criminal investigation must be submitted immediately after they are received. If making a decision within such a time frame is impossible, a period of three days is provided .
After this, the investigator sends a written response to the culprit. Important! The complaint is submitted to the prosecutor's office, court or the head of the investigative body. The deadline for its consideration is set within 10 days. An application for recusal is subject to consideration immediately upon receipt.
Results of consideration
Based on the results of consideration of the submitted petition, a decision is made to reject or approve it.
When the authorized person has made a decision according to which the petition must be granted, it will be necessary to carry out the actions requested by the guilty person. The suspect or accused may ask in a petition to bring into the case additional witnesses or eyewitnesses who were not previously involved in it, to provide new material evidence, etc.
When it comes to a complaint, the result of its consideration can also be satisfaction or refusal. When a complaint is satisfied, in which the perpetrator indicates that illegal actions have been committed against him, then the persons who committed these actions must be punished.
Features of criminal liability
Experts in the field of jurisprudence are convinced that criminal liability is a special form of influence of the state on society, especially on persons who break the law. Therefore, it has its own characteristics:
- A criminal is considered a person whose guilt in committing an unlawful act is proven in accordance with the procedure established by law.
- The forms of implementation of criminal liability are strictly regulated by law for each specific offense.
- Specially created state institutions are responsible for the execution and imposition of punishments.
- Society’s negative assessment of an unlawful act lies not only in the punishment itself (fine, arrest, imprisonment), but also in the very fact of having a criminal record.
At what age does criminal responsibility begin?
The age of criminal responsibility established by the legislation of many CIS countries is 16 years. That is, when it is achieved at the time of the commission of an offense, a person is obliged to fully answer for his unlawful acts. It is believed that sixteen-year-old persons subject to criminal liability are sane and capable of realizing the offenses committed. This is why it is important to use legal enforcement measures.
However, for serious and especially serious crimes, this threshold is reduced to 14 years. Such offenses include:
- murder or kidnapping;
- intentional infliction of harm to health of moderate and severe severity;
- rape;
- robbery;
- robbery;
- terrorism and some others.
Features of criminal liability of minors
In the legislation, criminal liability of minors is considered a special type, applicable to persons who were between 14 and 18 years old at the time of the crime. In some situations, it also applies to people aged 18 to 20 years. It has specific nuances:
- A limited number of punishments, which include only a fine, deprivation of the right to engage in certain activities, work (compulsory or correctional), restriction or imprisonment.
- Reducing the terms and amounts of punishment applied, in contrast to the same for adults. So, for example, the maximum term of imprisonment is 10 years.
- Juvenile offenders serve their sentences in special correctional institutions.
- By a court decision, penalties may be changed to compulsory educational influence in state educational or closed-type treatment and educational organizations.
- The conditions for applying parole also differ.
- For minors, the statute of limitations for committing a crime and the periods for expunging criminal records have been reduced.
What is meant by crime
In the Criminal Code, a crime is understood as a socially dangerous act that is prohibited by the specified act.
There is a penalty for committing such an act. The criminal intentions that the guilty person has are not immediately translated into actions in all cases; for this reason, the commission of an unlawful act has several stages. The first stage is called preparation. This stage involves the commission of preparatory actions by the guilty person. This point is the starting point on the path to a criminal result. When a person’s actions are stopped at this stage, they are subject to assessment taking into account the provisions of Article 30 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation. It is worth noting that this rule applies only to the commission of grave and especially grave acts.
Next comes the attempted stage, which includes actions that were not completed by the perpetrator for reasons beyond his control. The third stage is the completed crime. The act is considered completed when all the characteristics inherent in the composition are present.
When assigning punishment for preparation and attempt, reference must be made to the provisions of Article 30 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation. When a judge assigns a punishment, the degree and nature of the public danger of the act that was committed must be taken into account. In addition, the reasons why the perpetrators did not fully implement their plans are taken into account.
Important! The legislator indicates that the amount of punishment for preparation cannot exceed 1/2, and in the case of an attempt, 3/4 of what is prescribed in the law for the completed act. Download for viewing and printing:
Article 30 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation “Preparation for a crime and attempted crime”
What can they be prosecuted for?
Criminal prosecution is regulated at the state level.
Authorities are developing laws that include prohibitions of a criminal legal nature. In case of violation of established prohibitions, the violator is held accountable. The prohibition is formulated on the assumption of an action that may be dangerous to society. The laws also prohibit actions that have already been committed in practice.
Criminal liability is applied in cases where other methods and punishments have not led to the necessary results. The implementation of responsibility begins at the moment when a person violates the established prohibition. The procedure for bringing to criminal responsibility begins with the initiation of a criminal case, after which the search for the culprit and the collection of evidence are carried out.
The relationship between criminal liability and administrative
It is legally established that no person can be held accountable twice for the same act .
In a situation where there is a resolution to initiate a criminal case, the proceedings for an administrative violation do not begin, but what was started is terminated. If a situation arises where administrative proceedings are already underway and it is necessary to initiate a criminal case, the proceedings regarding the violation are terminated, otherwise the constitutional attack is not observed.
Situations may arise when, instead of criminal liability, a person is brought to administrative liability. This is permitted when committing a crime of minor gravity. In this case, correction is allowed by bringing to the perpetrator measures of state coercion that are not related to criminal law.
Article 86 of the Criminal Code talks about releasing a person from criminal liability with further prosecution for administrative liability. Two conditions must be met:
- minor crime;
- the damage caused was compensated or the damage was made up for in another way;
- the person is brought to justice for the first time;
- the perpetrator reaches the age of sixteen;
- there are reasons to believe that the person will improve through the application of administrative punishment.
Compensation for harm can be expressed in the return of money or property that was stolen. Full compensation for moral damages is also taken into account. Making amends is allowed by apologizing, providing financial or other assistance to the victim.
It is worth noting that the listed actions can be carried out at the suggestion of law enforcement agencies, or on the personal initiative of the perpetrator. The conditions regarding reaching the age of 16 years are related to the fact that administrative responsibility applies precisely from this age.
Important! To make a decision regarding the correction of the offender through administrative punishment, it is necessary to take into account the characteristics of the offender’s personality and analyze his data.
The powers regarding release from criminal liability with further involvement in administrative liability are granted to the judge. This rule is enshrined in Article 30 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of the Russian Federation. It is noted that such an action is permissible when a criminal case has already been initiated and during the investigation or inquiry the circumstances of the committed act have been established. This means that without initiating a criminal case or conducting an inquiry, the application of Article 86 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation is not allowed.
This article of the Criminal Code provides for the punishment that is applied to those found guilty. With release from criminal liability, the case is terminated. It is worth noting that the procedure is not permitted if the accused or victim has spoken out against it.
Download for viewing and printing:
Article 86 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation “Criminal record”
Article 30 of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation “Composition of the court”
Grounds for criminal liability
The Criminal Code specifies certain grounds when criminal liability may be applicable:
- Criminal liability arises for the commission of a particularly dangerous act that has signs of a crime. That is, specific actions are taken into account, not thoughts or intentions.
- Not any illegal action, but only what is prescribed in the Criminal Code can be considered as such. After all, there are disciplinary, administrative and civil offenses.
- This type of punishment is applied only when the guilt of the offender is proven by the court after a legal investigation process.
- The existence of a crime is also considered a prerequisite for application. It includes the criminal himself, his act and attitude towards the crime, as well as social relations that were endangered due to the offense committed.
Circumstances mitigating criminal liability
In all countries, criminal liability can be mitigated by a number of circumstances. That is, such factors that facilitate punishment for what they have done. These may include:
- The offender is a minor.
- The perpetrator is pregnant or has young children.
- Misdemeanors of minor or moderate severity, committed for the first time.
- Crimes that an individual committed out of compassion or due to difficult life circumstances.
- The illegality and immorality of the victim’s actions that led to the commission of the crime.
- Acts committed under duress or against one’s will due to being dependent on other persons.
- Turning in and assisting the investigation.
- If the criminal, immediately after committing an offense, provides assistance to the victim or voluntarily agrees to compensate for the harm caused and some others.
Circumstances excluding criminal liability
In situations strictly defined by law, an action that has signs of a criminal offense does not result in criminal liability. For example, in the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation such factors include only:
- Necessary defense, in which a person commits illegal actions in relation to an individual who uses violence against the defender or other persons.
- Offenses when detaining a criminal to bring him to the authorities in order to prevent him from committing new crimes.
- An extreme necessity, when the harm caused is less than the prevented damage to personal interests, the interests of third parties, society and the state.
- The use of physical or mental coercion on a person in order to achieve the commission of an unlawful act.
- Execution of instructions or orders.
Under what article of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation does tax agent liability arise?
For tax offenses, responsibility arises not only for taxpayers, but also for tax agents.
A tax agent is a person obliged to timely calculate the amount of tax payments, withhold funds from taxpayers and transfer them to the state budget (Article 24 of the Tax Code of the Russian Federation). A striking example of a tax agent is an employer who withholds personal income tax from the salaries of its employees and independently transfers it to the Federal Tax Service. Provisions of Art. 199.1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation establishes the extent of liability of a tax agent who does not fulfill the obligations assigned to him in order to satisfy personal interests. If the damage caused to the state is large, the court may impose a fine from the violator in the amount of 100 to 300 thousand rubles. or in the form of income for a period of time from 1 to 2 years. In addition, the court has the right to send the convicted person to forced labor for up to 2 years or imprison him for the same period.
If the amount of arrears corresponds to the status of especially large, the convicted person will have to pay a fine in the amount of 200 thousand to 0.5 million rubles. or in the amount of income for a period of time from 1 to 2 years. As an alternative punishment, the court may impose the obligation to perform forced labor (for no more than 5 years) or deprive the offender of liberty for up to 6 years. An additional penalty may be a ban on working in a certain position for up to 3 years.
Functions of criminal liability
In legal law, the onset of criminal liability is intended to perform the following functions:
- Regulatory
. That is, citizens of the state must understand the boundaries between acceptable and illegal acts. - Preventive
. This includes crime prevention. - Punitive
. That is, imposing punishment on a person who has already committed a crime. - Educational
. This function is related to the preventive one and consists in the formation of norms and beliefs about the inadmissibility of certain types of acts. - Restorative
. Punishment of the criminal is intended to restore broken social relations.
Principles of criminal liability
All applied criminal liability measures must be implemented in accordance with generally accepted principles:
- Legality
. That is, all punishments should be applied exclusively on the basis of laws adopted in the state. - Equality of all citizens
before the law, regardless of social characteristics. - The inevitability of responsibility
. Every offense is subject to punishment unless there are circumstances excluding it. - Personal guilt
. That is, everyone is responsible only for crimes that are committed by him, and not by someone else. - Justice
, that is, a person is responsible for one crime only once. - Humanism
. Law and law are aimed at protecting man as the highest value
Persons who are responsible for tax offenses
Responsibility for committing tax offenses lies not only with organizations, but also with individuals, and the latter are not held accountable if they were under the age of 16 at the time of the violation of the law.
Sanctions for the violator, in accordance with Art. 107 of the Tax Code of the Russian Federation apply regardless of whether the offense was committed intentionally or through negligence. However, it is obvious that the punishment for intentional failure to comply with the requirements of the legislator will be more severe than for a violation committed accidentally.
The conditions that must be met when making a decision to apply sanctions to a citizen or organization are determined by Art. 108 Tax Code of the Russian Federation:
- The violator can be brought to justice only in the manner prescribed by law.
- Repeated prosecution of a person for the same violation is not permitted.
Forms of implementation of criminal liability
It was already mentioned above that the legislation clearly defines the forms of criminal liability, that is, those types of punishments that follow the commission of certain offenses. These include:
- Fines, that is, monetary penalties of a certain amount.
- Deprivation of the right to engage in certain activities or hold a certain position in state or local government bodies.
- Deprivation of military or special rank, awards or titles, restriction of military service.
- Compulsory work that the offender is obliged to perform in his free time for the benefit of society for free.
- Correctional work, which differs from the previous paragraph in that it may be the only punishment.
- Forced labor can replace imprisonment and is carried out in places designated by authorities.
- Restriction of freedom. During this period, the offender is obliged, for example, not to leave his home at a certain time of the day or to travel outside the municipality.
- Arrest or isolation of the suspect from society for a period of 1 to 6 months.
- Imprisonment for a specific term or for life.
Responsibility under Art. 198 and 199 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation
Provisions of Art.
198 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation determines the responsibility of an individual (including individual entrepreneurs) for tax evasion, realized by failure to submit mandatory documentation to the regulatory authority. In the same way, it is a violation to deliberately include in such documentation information that does not correspond to reality. If the damage is large, the violator will have to pay a fine of 100 to 300 thousand rubles. Alternatively, the court may rule on the recovery of funds earned by the culprit for a period of one to two years, or sentence him to forced labor (for no more than a year). As a last resort, the court may imprison the person for up to a year.
For evasion, the size of which is particularly large, the violator can be fined in the amount of 200 thousand to 0.5 million rubles. or the equivalent of his income for a period of one and a half to 3 years. In addition, the court may sentence the perpetrator to forced labor for up to 3 years or imprisonment for the same period.
In Art. 199 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation establishes liability for a similar violation of the law committed by an organization. The sanction for the manager in this case is more stringent: for large-scale damage, the violator will be fined in the amount of 100 thousand to 0.5 million rubles. or be deprived of income for a period of one to two years. In addition, the court may decide to subject him to forced labor (for no more than 2 years), arrest him (up to six months) or imprison him for up to 2 years.
A particularly large amount of damage is punishable by a fine in the amount of earnings for a period of one to three years or in the form of a fixed amount from 200 to 500 thousand rubles. The court may also impose forced labor on the convicted person for up to 5 years or imprison him for up to 6 years.
Criminal liability - punishments
The legislation establishes that if an individual was brought to criminal liability, then he served the sentence imposed by the court verdict. It is necessary for:
- Restoring social justice.
- Criminal corrections.
- Prevention of new illegal actions.
Responsibility for a criminal offense in the form of punishment may be:
- Basic
. That is, applied on their own and not used to enhance the effect of other punishments. This could be either arrest or forced labor, or life imprisonment or the death penalty. - Additional
, used together with the main punishment to enhance its effect. For example, a fine or deprivation of the right to hold a certain position.
Statute of limitations for criminal prosecution
In criminal law, there is also such a concept as the statute of limitations for bringing to criminal liability. This term refers to a period of time after which punishment for a particular offense is not applied. It begins from the moment a crime is committed or a court decision is made and can be suspended or interrupted.
Liability for a criminal offense has different statutes of limitations in different countries from 2 months. up to 35 years old. For some crimes in international law such terms are not provided. In the Russian Federation, punishment is not applied if:
- 2 or 6 years have passed since the commission of minor or moderate offenses.
- 10 or 15 years have passed since the grave or especially grave crime.
Types of liability for tax offenses
Liability for tax offenses depends on a number of factors, which must be assessed when deciding on the punishment applied to the taxpayer.
Moreover, the current Tax Code of the Russian Federation is not the only regulatory document establishing sanctions and the procedure for their application to the violator. The Code of Administrative Offenses and the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation also determine penalties for tax offenses. The division of illegal acts into different categories and the application of different types of liability to them is due to their diverse nature and the different amount of damage that their commission entails. That is why, in addition to tax liability for tax offenses, administrative and criminal liability may arise.
A violator can be brought to any of the listed types of liability only in court, and the type of court to which the tax authority applies depends on which category the taxpayer belongs to.
So, the claim is filed:
- to the arbitration court if the violator has the status of an individual entrepreneur or is an organization;
- to a court of general jurisdiction if the law was violated by an individual who is not an entrepreneur.
Exemption from criminal liability
If government authorities refuse to continue criminal prosecution, then we can talk about releasing the person from responsibility for the crime committed. In different countries of the world, the grounds for exemption from criminal liability may differ, but most accept the following conditions:
- Expiration of the statute of limitations for the offense, as discussed above.
- Active repentance or voluntary actions of the perpetrator aimed at compensating or making amends for the harm caused.
- Official reconciliation with the victim with compensation for damage.
Pre-trial, extra-judicial and judicial stages
The extrajudicial stage of consideration of the case is due to the fact that there is no appeal to law enforcement agencies and the issue is resolved peacefully. The pre-trial stage involves conducting a preliminary investigation or inquiry into the case.
What to do to resolve the issue without contacting law enforcement agencies
After committing a crime, the perpetrator has the opportunity to resolve the issue with the victim peacefully.
This rule can mainly be applied to crimes of minor gravity. In other cases, this possibility is assessed based on the consequences resulting from the commission of the crime. When it comes to the theft of someone else's property, it is possible to reach an agreement with the owner peacefully, without contacting law enforcement agencies. In this case, the perpetrator must compensate for the damage caused by the crime and, if necessary, pay for moral damage.
Also, the guilt can be made up for by applying changes and performing other actions that the victim considers sufficient to forgive the perpetrator.
Video about reconciliation of parties in a criminal case
What to do if the victim does not want to resolve the issue peacefully
In such a situation, the optimal solution to the problem would be to agree with the victim’s decision.
Otherwise, a claim for invasion of privacy may also be made when the perpetrator's efforts to reconcile become too intrusive. For example, if a person enters the house of another without permission, then this action is punishable under Article 139 of the Criminal Code.
Download for viewing and printing:
Article 139 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation “Violation of the inviolability of the home”
When criminal proceedings are initiated
Criminal proceedings are initiated at the time of initiation of criminal proceedings.
To begin this procedure, a competent person must issue an order to initiate proceedings. If there are compelling reasons to believe that the act was committed by a certain person, then a case is initiated against him. When the investigation does not have sufficient information about the guilty person, the case must be initiated based on the fact. In practice, there are several reasons by which a case is initiated:
- a statement drawn up by the victim;
- confession of the criminal;
- a message containing information regarding a committed or impending act;
- a resolution sent by the prosecutor to the investigative or inquiry body to resolve issues of initiation;
- data collected by the body performing functions in the field of taxation.
In addition, there must be sufficient grounds that the act was actually committed. The Criminal Procedure Code lists the circle of persons who have the authority to initiate a case.
